Skip to main content

Dressing as the Minister - clothing choices edition

So what is the minister suppose to look like? That's a much debated topic. 15 years ago when I encountered my first female pastor and said that I wanted to become a minister myself I was advised that for at least for the first year that I should never let anyone in my congregation see me without a skirt/dress on. A congregation was upset because I generally wear flip flops, not knowing or understanding that my feet are a very odd size and finding shoes that are comfortable to wear is very difficult and frustrating. The pastor of my current congregation has had numerous members come up to him and tell him that he does not look much like a minister because he's wearing a t-shirt and jeans when preaching. So what does or is a minister suppose to look like? Are ministers expected to be always in dress casual clothing? Should I always have a skirt hidden in my desk drawer/car trunk in case someone comes through the door? Should I be spending quality time every week making sure that my dress shoes are polished?

Coming from a youth and children's ministry background and then a hospital chaplain let me tell you that I don't agree with the idea of always being in business casual. If I did that in my 10 plus years of ministry I would have spent enough money to feed a third world country on replacing all of the clothing and shoes that have been destroyed doing ministry. Last time I checked, my pay checks never were that much to cover that type of a clothing bill. I don't see myself changing light bulbs in a skirt either - a task that I've done often in many churches.

So what is the dress code of a minister? Yes I firmly agree that there are times when it's important to look nice - weddings, funerals, etc. - but I also don't believe that just because my office/study is located within the four walls of a congregation that I have to have on dressy clothes. If one thinks of the church as a home then why wouldn't we want to be comfortable in our home? Why do we have to dress to impress Jesus when even Jesus took a break, took off his sandals and enjoying being comfortable? I'm not saying that it needs to be "wear your pajamas to church day" but if I or another pastor feels comfortable in blue jeans and t-shirt then why is that a bad thing? I know that I don't enjoy talking to someone who is dressed way above me. I want to be able to feel comfortable and like I can relate to the person I'm talking too. Clothing is one way that folks are able to look and see if they may have something in common with the other. Running around in suit and tie/skirts and dress clothes doesn't help people feel like they can relate.

So what's the proper response to the comments of "you don't look like a pastor" and/or "you need to wear certain items?" I like asking the question immediately to the person of "well what is a pastor suppose to look like?" The often disarms a person and makes them realize the words that just came out of their mouth. But then the next series of question has to deal with what lies at the base of the assumptions. There are some ministers who are very comfortable always being in Sunday best clothing and that's great for them. I believe that casual clothes are acceptable too. Neither is right or wrong but I think there's room at the table for both.

Comments

Popular posts from this blog

Can you quote the Bible?

In a conversation with a more conservative Christian then me (take in mind I call myself a bed-wetting liberal and I’m also a big time Process Theologian) the person started rambling off scripture quotes (proof texting really) to make a point. I have never claimed to be a great memorizer of anything. And even though I have read the Bible many times and own many copies of the Bible, I am still not a person who can just pull out scripture references in mid conversation. I do have several verses that I turn to and love dearly but I can’t tell you word for word what John 2:5 or Ruth 1:4 says. This got me thinking, why do Christians really feel the need to qualify their faith based on the amount of scripture that they can recite from memory? While it may be very handy to be able to quote scripture in a variety of situations, I believe that this can be dangerous. Proof texting (pulling scripture, from any religion, to support an argument without careful and learned consideration for its cont

Conflict in a Church - 1

As I watch a congregation I’m very familiar with spiral out of control I’m forced to sit and reflect on what went so wrong? Why does it seem like the only options are to either fire the minister or close the doors? When I think back the problems began before this minister was even hired. This is a congregation that wants to and likes to say that it’s a welcoming and friendly place. But in reality it isn’t and hasn’t been for the 20 some years I’ve known it. Groups of people made sure that other people knew that they were below them. They were operating then on the mentality that we did this 50 years ago so we need to keep doing it. And as for being welcoming… well with you weren’t middle-class, preferably upper middle-class and white well don’t bother walking through the door. These are all issues that existed 20 years ago and were never addressed. And shockingly these are still issues in the congregation today. Clearly this church has decided to put its head in the sand and live in th

4th of July Worship

I am an American; born here in the USA, lived here all of my life. I do like this country. I don’t always agree with the way it works or who’s running it but I’m here and I know that there are millions of people who are less fortunate in the world then me. I am thankful that I have the rights that I have and the access to so much. I know the “Star Spangled Banner” and I sing patriotic songs and like most of them. However, on July 4th Sunday (or the Sunday closest to the 4th of July), I find it hard to be in worship in congregations that structure the theme around God Bless the USA/America. I find it hard to sit there and look at church chancels that are adorned with the American flag and if people noticed where I sit it’s so it’s not in my eyesight while I worship. It bothers me that people get all festive, wearing red, white and blue to worship, but can’t remember the colors of the liturgical year. This bothers me because as Christians we are called to worship the God of all people